On Sunday evening as I was thinking about this blog assignment, I turned on the television and TBS was showing the movie “What Women Want.” For those that have not seen the movie, the main character, played by Mel Gibson, gains the uncanny ability to “read” the minds of the women around him. With this ability, his character proceeds to cut a swathe through the female world. He is sensitive, insightful, and able to engage women that used to hate him in deep conversations. He has gained the powerful tool of insight into the female psyche. Conveniently he also works in an ad agency and uses these new found thoughts and the female perspective to bolster his creative abilities and become even more successful. What really jumped out about this film was how the insight was being gained. Mel’s character, once he harnessed his powers, would sneakily follow women and observe their daily activities. He placed himself in situations that would allow him to observe women going about their lives. His advantage over others was that he was able to hear the inner thoughts of the women. This allowed him to be able to view the lives of those women around him and also understand what they truly felt about the situation or whether or not they even cared about the action they were doing.
This example illustrates how gaining insight to a consumer’s need is extremely difficult and must be balanced. Taken alone, Mel’s character’s observation skills are only able to get him so far into what the women really require. This same principle applies to consumer research. Observing users of particular products or in certain situations, even when they don’t realize you are observing them, does not allow the ability to understand what they truly feel. It is only part of the entire equation. Without additional information, the observation can be just a giant waste of time. Another problem with observing people is that they must realize that they are being observed. You run the risk of invasion of privacy that the character in the movie must deal with when he goes a bit too far.
As we discussed in class, there are multiple ways to gain insight with regards to a consumer’s specific needs. Unfortunately, taken alone, each technique falls short of providing the entire picture. Only when taking different perspectives is one able to fully understand the shifting planes that is a consumer’s needs. Observation coupled with interviews, and questionnaires allow different information to be taken into account and provide a much fuller picture.